Pope Leo XIV and the Future of Catholic Social Teaching

Dennis P. McCann

 

Abstract

The question to be explored in this paper is what difference, if any, the installation of Pope Leo XIV will make in the development of Catholic Social Teaching (CST). Leo's initial appeals to CST, especially his Apostolic Exhortation Dilexi te (2025), are presented in continuity with the emphasis on Christian spirituality that found its climax in Pope Francis' final encyclical, Dilexit nos (2024). Not only are the two statements stylistically convergent, but both aim at inviting readers to take a stand, responding to Jesus Christ's call for a change of heart, an act of "reparation" restoring our capacity for heartfelt communion with God and our fellow human beings. While Dilexit nos explores the witness of those saints who enrich our understanding of the Sacred Heart of Christ, Dilexi te invites us to explore the development of Christian practices caring for the poor, sharing their lives, learning from them, culminating in an exhortation to "almsgiving" that will enable us to become personally involved with them. Leo's contribution to CST, so far, consists in urging us to take a stand anchored firmly in the Sacred Heart of Christ.

On November 22, 2025, Pope Leo XIV, just six months after his election to the Papacy, during his weekly audience with pilgrims who had come to Rome, made the following statement about his fellow American, Ms. Dorothy Day, the founder along with Peter Maurin of the Catholic Worker Movement. Pope Leo's remarks are a vivid example of how he is approaching the renewal of CST today:

"I would like to recall a small but great American woman, Dorothy Day, who lived in the last century. She had fire within. Dorothy Day took a stand. She saw that the development model of her country did not create the same opportunities for everyone; she understood that the dream was a nightmare for too many of them, that as a Christian she had to become involved with workers, migrants, those discarded by a deadly economy. She wrote and she served: it is important to unite the mind, the heart and the hands. This is what taking a stand is. She wrote as a journalist; that is, she thought and she made others think. Writing is important. And so is reading, today more than ever. And then Dorothy served meals, gave clothes, dressed and ate like those she served: she united mind, heart and hands. In this way, to hope is to take a stand." (Pope Leo, "Catechesis 9")

"Taking a stand"—which resonates deeply with Confucian teaching (Analects, 6:30) which indicates that helping others make their stand is the most effective way to "establish oneself" (立身) (lishēn), the "method of Humanity"—is the key to understanding what Leo XIV means to do with CST. As we shall see, Leo's recovery of CST's traditions recalls primarily those people whose taking a stand created pathways for others to follow.

So far Leo's contribution to CST, in less than a year, consists in his Apostolic Exhortation, Dilexi te, issued on October 4, 2025, as well as his various shorter pieces issued as "catechesis" for his Wednesday Papal audiences, and other occasional addresses to various groups. Among these, at this time, the most significant are his reflections on the conflict involving Iran and its allies with the USA, Israel, and their allies. As is evident in his book, E pace sia!, recently published in English as Peace be with you! (Leo XIV, 2026), it is clear that Leo's teaching is in close continuity with the work of his predecessor, Pope Francis, especially his final encyclical, Dilexit nos (Francis, 2024). The Gospel of Peace preached by Leo focuses on the heart and its need for healing:

"Even before it is crushed on the battlefield, peace is defeated in the human heart when we give in to selfishness and greed and when we allow partisan interests to prevail instead of looking to the common good.... Depersonalizing others is the first step in any war. To know others, on the other hand, is a foretaste of peace. But in order to know, one must first know how to love. Saint Augustine said that 'no one can be known except through friendship'." (Leo XIV, 2026)

Leo's Apostolic Exhortation on Love for the Poor, Dilexi te (Leo XIV, 2025), acknowledges that the statement was virtually complete before Francis' death on Easter Monday (April 21, 2025), and that Leo has made it his own by "adding some reflections and to issue it at the beginning of my own pontificate, since I share the desire of my beloved predecessor that all Christians come to appreciate the close connection between Christ's love and his summons to care for the poor" (Dilexi te, par. 3).

Indeed, Dilexit nos ("On the Human and Divine Love of the Heart of Jesus Christ," Francis, 2024), may be considered the preamble to their common approach to CST. As Francis comments:

"The present document can help us see that the teaching of the social Encyclicals Laudato Si' and Fratelli Tutti is not unrelated to our encounter with the love of Jesus Christ. For it is by drinking of that same love that we become capable of forging bonds of fraternity, of recognizing the dignity of each human being, and of working together to care for our common home." (Dilexit nos, par. 217).

Dilexit nos, which echoes St. Paul's teaching on God's love for us in and through Christ (Romans 8:37), as well as testimony given in the Letter of St. John (1 John 4:16), focuses on the heart, and its centrality in Christian spirituality and anthropology. Our hearts are significant because of the Sacred Heart of Jesus through whom God's love is communicated to us.

Dilexit nos begins with an attempt to recover the language of the heart, obscured and distorted by so many cultural trends today. The lesson is that our response to God's love must begin with restoring our capacities for human interaction expressed in the language of the heart. Our path toward recovery is marked by the cloud of witnesses celebrated in Catholic tradition who showed us how to take a stand, saints such as St. Ambrose of Milan (339–397) (par. 102), St. Augustine of Hippo (354–430) (par. 103), St. Ignatius of Loyola (1491–1556) (par. 144–5), Sts. Francis de Sales (1567–1622) and Jane Frances de Chantal (1572–1641) (par. 114–118), St. Vincent de Paul (1581–1660) (par. 180), Saint Margaret Mary Alacoque (1647–1690) (par. 119–124), St. John Henry Newman (1801–1890) (par. 26), as well as more recent guides such as St. Charles de Foucauld (1858–1916) (par. 129–132) and St. Therese of the Child Jesus (1873–1897) (par. 133–142), and several others, none of whom are usually remembered within recitations of CST. Nevertheless, Francis observes that their vivid insights into the relationship of human hearts and the Sacred Heart of Jesus is the proper point of departure for practices consistent with CST. Toward the end of Dilexit nos, Francis discusses "Christian reparation," the actions of Christians that will contribute to a "civilization of love":

"Saint John Paul II also observed that 'to build the civilization of love', [197] our world today needs the heart of Christ. Christian reparation cannot be understood simply as a congeries of external works, however indispensable and at times admirable they may be. These need a 'mystique', a soul, a meaning that grants them strength, drive and tireless creativity. They need the life, the fire and the light that radiate from the heart of Christ." (par. 184)

Dilexit nos maps the logic of "Christian reparation" showing how the experiences of the saints who dared to embrace the heart of Jesus actually prepare the way for a renewal of what CST envisions as "integral human development."

The point of departure for such a response may begin with the observations of St. Francis de Sales who focused on the words of Jesus: "Learn from me; for I am gentle and humble in heart (Mt 11:29)" (par. 178). Embracing the heart of Christ involves recovery of one's own capacity for heart-to-heart responses, through the confession of one's own complicity in the ruin of this world, concrete attempts to be reconciled with those whom we have injured, and a resolve to "offer the heart of Christ a new possibility of spreading in this world the flames of his ardent and gracious love":

"This involves more than simply the 'consolation' of Christ...; it finds expression in acts of fraternal love by which we heal the wounds of the Church and of the world. In this way, we offer the healing power of the heart of Christ new ways of expressing itself." (Dilexit nos, par. 200)

CST will find its mission in the future, if and only if, it regards itself as a projection of the heart of Christ. Its policies for social justice, its development of strategies for reforming worldly institutions, its attempts to form alliances through dialogue with others, must ultimately be anchored in a sense of fraternity inspired by genuinely Christian spirituality—a "mystique," as Francis points out—that will respond to the world's need for reparation. This is what Leo means by taking a stand.

Dilexit nos, then, is a preamble to Dilexi te, a fitting first step toward reparation, since it addresses the worsening problem of global poverty, now threatening to destabilize all social structures, trying to cope with catastrophic climate change and its consequences. Dilexi te, stylistically, reads like a corollary to Dilexit nos, its practical application developed in light of a proper reading of the signs of the times. Leo begins his reflections by reaffirming the Church's "preferential option for the poor" (par. 16): "Love for the Lord, then, is one with love for the poor," as is amply demonstrated in the Bible, for example, in Mt 25:40. "This is not a matter of mere human kindness but a revelation: contact with those who are lowly and powerless is a fundamental way of encountering the Lord of history. In the poor, he continues to speak to us" (par. 5). Dilexi te then explains this "revelation" by showing, first, through reflection on Biblical teachings, that the authenticity of our rituals of worship should be tested by our demonstrated care for the poor and the sick:

"For this reason, works of mercy are recommended as a sign of the authenticity of worship, which, while giving praise to God, has the task of opening us to the transformation that the Spirit can bring about in us, so that we may all become an image of Christ and his mercy towards the weakest. In this sense, our relationship with the Lord, expressed in worship, also aims to free us from the risk of living our relationships according to a logic of calculation and self-interest. We are instead open to the gratuitousness that surrounds those who love one another and, therefore, share everything in common" (par. 27).

As in Confucian teaching on (立身) (lishēn), the "method of Humanity," CST thus begins with rectifying our rituals—in Christian context, this requires achieving authenticity in the worship of God. Care for the poor is essential in making a stand. Similarly, Dilexi te invokes the warning given in the First Letter of John (1 John 3:17): "How does God's love abide in anyone who has the world's goods and sees a brother or sister in need and yet refuses help?" (par. 30). Also remembered in this context is the Letter of James (2:14–17), showing that its teachings on the relationship of "faith" and "works"—often disparaged in the abstract—is concretely about the relationship of the poor and the rich:

"What good is it, my brothers and sisters, if you say you have faith but do not have works? Can faith save you? If a brother or sister is naked and lacks daily food, and one of you says to them, 'Go in peace; keep warm and eat your fill,' and yet you do not supply their bodily needs, what is the good of that? So faith by itself, if it has no works, is dead" (par. 29)

As Leo rightly reminds his readers:

"The message of God's word is so clear and direct, so simple and eloquent, that no ecclesial interpretation has the right to relativize it. The Church's reflection on these texts ought not to obscure or weaken their force, but urge us to accept their exhortations with courage and zeal. Why complicate something so simple?" (par. 31)

To clarify the Way indicated by such texts, Leo's Dilexi te, like Francis' Dilexit nos, invokes a cloud of witnesses, beginning with an exploration of passages from both the Hebrew Scriptures and the New Testament. It moves on from there to show the depth of Christian commitment to caring for the poor, by citing pivotal examples from the Fathers of the Church, Sts. Ignatius of Antioch and Polycarp of Smyrna (par. 39), St. Justin Martyr (par. 40), St. John Chrysostom—acknowledged as "the most ardent preacher on social justice" (par. 41), St. Ambrose of Milan—who is quoted as saying, "What you give to the poor is not your property, but theirs. Why have you appropriated what was given for common use?" (par. 43)—and St. Augustine of Hippo (par. 44). Augustine, the founder of Leo's own religious order, taught that "the poor are not just people to be helped, but the sacramental presence of the Lord." In his view, "fidelity to Augustine's teachings requires not only the study of his works, but also a readiness to live radically his call to conversion, which necessarily includes the service of charity" (par. 47).

In later times, including our own, the significance of caring for the poor is evident in founders of religious orders specifically dedicated to comforting the poor, the sick and those languishing in prisons (par. 49–62), as well as in Papal pronouncements usually featured in histories of CST, with special notice given to the contributions of Popes Leo XIII, John XXIII, Paul VI, John Paul II, and Benedict XVI (pars. 82–88). Pope Francis' witness is developed particularly with reference to his ministry in Argentina and Latin America, where he supported the bishops' efforts at Medellin and Puebla to develop the "preferential option for the poor." (Par. 89–90). Particularly noteworthy for Leo is Francis' development of St. John Paul II's observations on "social sin":

"In his Encyclical Dilexit Nos, Pope Francis reminded us that social sin consolidates a 'structure of sin within society,' and is frequently 'part of a dominant mindset that considers normal or reasonable what is merely selfishness and indifference. This then gives rise to social alienation.' It then becomes normal to ignore the poor and live as if they do not exist. It then likewise seems reasonable to organize the economy in such a way that sacrifices are demanded of the masses in order to serve the needs of the powerful." (par. 93)

Highlighting such structures, and criticizing the ideologies that blind us to their malicious impact is an indication of recent developments in CST. Overcoming poverty still requires making sacrifices to assist those in need whom we encounter, but it also means developing our understanding of how institutions are formed, their potential for helping or harming others, and how to reform them for the sake of an authentically common good. Among the Catholic saints commemorated in Dilexi te, Leo thus acknowledges the impact of innovative Christian educators, such as Sts. Jean-Baptiste de la Salle (1651–1719) and John Bosco (1815–1888) (par. 69–70), as well as those who responded to the mass migrations of the 19th and 20th centuries, provoked by industrialization and the global spread of capitalism. Leo specifically acknowledges St. Frances Xavier Cabrini (1850–1917), the founder of the Missionary Sisters of the Sacred Heart, who was honored in 1950 as "the Patroness of all Migrants" by Pope Pius XII (par. 74). Pope Francis' concern for migrants is also noted here:

"Every human being is a child of God! He or she bears the image of Christ! We ourselves need to see, and then to enable others to see, that migrants and refugees do not only represent a problem to be solved, but are brothers and sisters to be welcomed, respected and loved. They are an occasion that Providence gives us to help build a more just society, a more perfect democracy, a more united country, a more fraternal world and a more open and evangelical Christian community" (par. 75).

St. Theresa of Calcutta, canonized in 2016 in light of her Sisters' diligent care for the poor languishing in the streets of India, is also acknowledged as "a universal icon of charity [who] lived to the fullest extent in favor of the most destitute, those discarded by society." Her witness was meant to demonstrate how a Christian should take a stand:

"We are wanting to proclaim the good news to the poor that God loves them, that we love them, that they are somebody to us, that they too have been created by the same loving hand of God, to love and to be loved. Our poor people are great people, are very lovable people, they do not need our pity and sympathy, they need our understanding love. They need our respect; they need that we treat them with dignity" (par. 77).

Mother Teresa's ministry of love with and for the poor is a perfect example of the way to take a stand, as we are invited to do, in CST. What is new and challenging here is the primacy of Biblical spirituality that must animate any and all attempts to develop the future of CST. Leo's summarizing remarks indicate that not only must our attempts to follow the Way outlined in CST be animated by a change of heart, a commitment to do "reparation" for our part in ruining God's world, but also it must give rise to works, not just public policy reforms as important as these may be, but also personal attempts to love the poor through dialogue, mutual understanding and collaboration.

Specifically, Leo urges us to renew the ancient Christian practice of "almsgiving". Here is how it may make a difference:

"Those inspired by true charity know full well that almsgiving does not absolve the competent authorities of their responsibilities, eliminate the duty of government institutions to care for the poor, or detract from rightful efforts to ensure justice. Almsgiving at least offers us a chance to halt before the poor, to look into their eyes, to touch them and to share something of ourselves with them. In any event, almsgiving, however modest, brings a touch of pietas into a society otherwise marked by the frenetic pursuit of personal gain" (par. 116).

The point of almsgiving is the possibility that it will reawaken the giver's capacity for heart-to-heart communication, especially with our fellow human beings who cry out for our help. As Leo observes:

"For this very reason, we Christians must not abandon almsgiving. It can be done in different ways, and surely more effectively, but it must continue to be done. It is always better at least to do something rather than nothing. Whatever form it may take, almsgiving will touch and soften our hardened hearts. It will not solve the problem of world poverty, yet it must still be carried out, with intelligence, diligence and social responsibility. For our part, we need to give alms as a way of reaching out and touching the suffering flesh of the poor" (par. 119).

Besides restoring Christian authenticity in our care for those in need, Leo's other expressed concerns—for example, regarding the American-Israeli war with Iran—further demonstrate the seriousness of CST's focus on a recovery of our capacities to overcome heartlessness. The "method of Humanity" as understood through Catholic faith and practice invites each of us to take a stand to reawaken our hearts to what love may offer.

 


Dennis P. McCann, Faculty Fellow, Silliman University, MRIJ Managing Editor.


REFERENCES

  • Confucius (1979). The Analects. D.C. Lau translation. London: Penguin Books.
  • Pope Francis (2024, October 24). "Encyclical Letter Dilexit nos of the Holy Father Francis on the Human and Divine Love of the Heart of Jesus Christ." Retrieved from https://www.vatican.va/content/francesco/en/encyclicals/documents/20241024-enciclica-dilexit-nos.html
  • Pope Leo XIV (2025, October 4). "Apostolic Exhortation Dilexi te of the Holy Father Leo XIV on Love for the Poor." Retrieved from https://www.vatican.va/content/leo-xiv/en/apost_exhortations/documents/20251004-dilexi-te.html
  • Pope Leo XIV (2025, November 22). "Catechesis 9. To hope is to take a stand. Dorothy Day," Jubilee Audience. Retrieved from https://www.iubilaeum2025.va/en/pellegrinaggio/calendario-giubileo/udienze-del-santo-padre/udienza-santo-padre-novembre-22.html
  • Pope Leo XIV (2026, February 24). "Pope Leo XIV: Only peaceful hearts can build just and lasting peace." New introduction to the English translation of E pace sia! New York: HarperCollins. Retrieved from https://www.vaticannews.va/en/pope/news/2026-02/popeleo-xiv-preface-peace-be-with-you-english-version.html

Click here to view the PDF version