Pope Leo XIV and His First Year as Pope

Thomas Worcester, SJ

 

Abstract

The election of Pope Leo XIV on 8 May 2025 showed that the cardinal electors were not bound by supposed exclusions, such as there could never be a pope from the United States. The significance of their choice of an Augustinian friar with dual nationality (US and Peru) is unfolding day by day, for the Church around the world, and for how this pope does or does not stand in continuity with Pope Francis, the Jesuit Pope. Thus far Pope Leo appears very much in tune with Pope Francis, especially on care for the poor, for immigrants and refugees, for the marginalized. Pope Leo's global travels will reveal more about his priorities, and what matters most to him, as he seeks to serve the church in all its diverse cultures, languages, traditions, hesitations, and hopes. He speaks often of peace, and the need to work for it, peace that is something very much needed given the abundance of conflicts today.

What follows in this article is in two parts: Part one, on 'reception' and some reactions to Pope Leo in the first months of his papacy, including his family and ancestry, his international experience, his intellectual inclinations, what appear to be his various priorities as pontiff. Part two examines selected homilies, speeches, addresses and an apostolic exhortation of Pope Leo.

Reception

The New York Times has been following the papacy of Pope Leo very closely. The very next day after the election of the first US born pope, the Times published an article on Leo as also the Peruvian Pope (Taj, Turewitz, and Glatsky, 9 May 2025). Written by three reporters, two in Peru and one in New York, this article emphasized how especially his years as bishop in Peru (2015–23) saw him much cherished as someone who remained close to the people, in particular in times of suffering.

The 15 June 2025 issue of the New York Times magazine devoted its cover story to Pope Leo's ancestry (Gates, 15 June 2025, pp. 26–33). This Pope's diverse ancestors include nobles, enslaved persons, slaveholders, and freedom fighters. His father's ancestors were mostly Italian or French; though most of his mother's ancestors were Spanish or French, some were black, and some were of mixed race, often referred to as mulattos. Some of the ancestors that came from France settled in Quebec, but in later generations some moved south, especially to Louisiana. Pope Leo's rather distant relations who remained in Canada even include prime ministers Pierre Trudeau and his son Justin Trudeau (Ibid., p. 32).

The 28 July 2025 issue of Time Magazine offers "The Making of the Pope," as its cover story, and includes a 1959 photograph showing the young Robert Prevost and his two brothers John and Louis with their mother Mildred, in front of a Chicago church (Luscome, 28 July 2025, pp. 26–31). The article that follows suggests that at a very young age Robert was already drawn to the priesthood, and behaved in such ways that led a neighbor to tell him he would be Pope one day (Ibid., p. 27). Also highlighted is how the future Pope was educated in theology and related disciplines not only with fellow clerics and other religious but with lay people, female and male.

When the Jesuit Jorge Bergoglio was elected pope in 2013 it was the first time since the early 1800s that a member of a religious order was chosen as pope. The cardinals again elected a member of a religious order in 2025. James K. A. Smith, an expert on St. Augustine, sees Augustinian priorities and themes as prominent in what Pope Leo says and does. These include discipleship as a journey and pilgrimage; our hearts as restless until they rest in God; the gospel as promising peace to the puzzled and the despairing (Smith, July/August 2025, pp. 42–44).

An interview with Cardinal Stephen Chow, SJ, bishop of Hong Kong, was published in America magazine (19 May 2025). Cardinal Chow emphasized the importance of discernment and listening to the Holy Spirit in electing a pope. Cardinal Chow did criticize the Vatican's resistance to using languages other than Latin and Italian, even with the very diverse group of voting cardinals. This was not the best way of proceeding for the conclave, and Cardinal Chow implied, for a global church.

At the end of the summer, on 2 September, Pope Leo hosted Cardinal Chow for conversation (presumably in English), largely regarding the Church in China. In an article in The Sunday Examiner of Hong Kong, Cardinal Chow shared that he found Pope Leo eager to learn more about China-Vatican relations and about the situation of the Church in China. The bishop of Hong Kong made two more points: when the Pope was superior general of the Augustinian order he made a trip to China; as Pope he intends to continue in the direction set by Pope Francis in dealing with China (Sunday Examiner.org.hk, 3 September 2025).

Ambrose Mong, OP, Research Associate at the Chinese University of Hong Kong, has published in The Way a very recent article on Leo XIV and the legacy of Leo XIII (Mong, January 2026, pp. 97–113). Mong examines ways in which the former aims to further the latter's work on social justice as well as on the dignity and rights of all persons. Leo XIII is often remembered for his enthusiastic promotion of Thomas Aquinas; Mong points out that Augustine was also cited frequently in many of Leo XIII's writings (Mong, Ibid., 109). Moreover, Leo XIII also did much to support the Order of St. Augustine in his own time, with the naming of Augustinian bishops and cardinals, in restoring Augustinian churches, and in helping in the construction of a new Augustinian headquarters in Rome. Most importantly, Mong sees Leo XIV as following and building upon Leo XIII in defending workers and their dignity, and in promoting not just charity but social justice (Mong, Ibid., p. 110).

Some Writings of Pope Leo XIV

As the head of the Dicastery for Bishops, Cardinal Prevost was already an important Vatican administrator when he was elected Pope on 8 May 2025. The tone of his homily, preached in St. Peter's Square on May 18 at the Mass for the beginning of his Pontificate, was a very humble one. Describing himself as a servant and a brother of God's people, walking with them, in a spirit that values different cultures living in harmony and love, Pope Leo seemed to echo much of what Pope Francis had preached many times (Leo XIV, 18 May 2025).

Pope Francis had chosen not to use Castel Gandolfo, the papal summer residence south of Rome, as a place for vacation or the like. But one thing he had done was initiate Borgo Laudato si', a part of the Castel Gandolfo property, henceforth to be a space devoted to promotion of protection of the environment, as so strongly advocated in Francis' 2015 encyclical Laudato si'. On 5 September 2025, Pope Leo went to Castel Gandolfo to inaugurate and bless Borgo Laudato si'; in his homily for the occasion, he described it as "a synthesis of extraordinary beauty...spirituality, nature, history, art, work and technology," a synthesis intended to exist in harmony (Leo XIV, 18 May 2025).

Pope Leo's Apostolic Exhortation Dilexi te of 4 October 2025, was addressed to all Christians on love for the poor (Pope Leo, 4 October 2025). Building on the priorities of Pope Francis, Pope Leo stresses that a choice in favor of the poor is not merely optional for authentic Christians, indeed anyone who claims to love God but lacks compassion for the poor is a liar. Charity for the poor is not enough if the structural causes of poverty are ignored.

On All Saints' Day, 1 November 2025, Pope Leo added Saint John Henry Newman to the list of Doctors of the Church; the Pope also named Newman, together with Thomas Aquinas, co-patron of the Church's education mission. Pope Leo added that when he reflects on schools and universities, he thinks of them as "laboratories of prophecy" where hope is lived (Pope Leo, 1 November 2025). Hope was central to the theme of the Jubilee year 2025 as articulated by Pope Francis, a Pope who often spoke with a prophetic voice.

Visiting Turkey and Lebanon, 27 November – 2 December, Pope Leo both participated in celebration of the 1700th anniversary of the Council of Nicaea and of the Nicene Creed and engaged with church and state leaders and many people in various venues in both Turkey and Lebanon. In his Apostolic Letter of 23 November 2025, Pope Leo stressed the Nicene Creed as a continuing source of ecumenical unity (Pope Leo, 23 November 2025).

In an Address to Organizers and Artists of the Concert with the Poor, 5 December 2025, Pope Leo stressed that this was the sixth edition of a "beautiful tradition" begun by Pope Francis, a tradition in which "our most fragile brothers and sisters" occupy the front seats. Pope Leo added that this tradition fits well with preparation for Christmas when we celebrate Jesus who was poor (Pope Leo, 5 December 2025).

Three days before Christmas, Pope Leo addressed the Roman curia for the "exchange of Christmas greetings." In one of his first years as pontiff, Pope Francis had used this same occasion for a rather severe critique of the curia, enumerating with them a list of some fifteen things wrong with them (Pope Francis, 22 December 2014). Pope Leo was milder in his 2025 address to the curia. Yet he did insist on the importance of a synodal church (perhaps not always appreciated by the curia?) and on fraternal friendship as essential for a healthy functioning of the curia, the curia where "the exercise of power, the desire to prevail, or the pursuit of personal interests are slow to change" (Pope Leo, 22 December 2025).

The prologue of the Gospel of John is the gospel read at Mass on Christmas day; in his homily on this text Pope Leo emphasized that it is a hymn about the Word of God who knew rejection and suffering. The path of the Word of God was a "rugged road, strewn with obstacles," but a path to peace. In his conclusion to the homily Pope Leo declared: "There will be peace when our monologues are interrupted and, enriched by listening, we fall to our knees before the humanity of the other" (Pope Leo, 25 December 2025).

On 6 January Pope Leo celebrated the Epiphany along with the formal closure of the Jubilee year 2025. In his homily at St. Peter's basilica, he emphasized that not only the Magi that brought gifts to the infant Jesus were on a journey, but so too all of us in our lives as Christians are pilgrims on a journey, in a Jubilee year, but also in one form or another at all times. Such a journey may be a special time for being surprised by God (Pope Leo, 6 January 2026).

The very next day saw Pope Leo open the extraordinary consistory of cardinals, in Synod Hall. In his address to the cardinals, he emphasized that this consistory is to be one of reflection and dialogue; a time to get to know one another; an occasion to offer a model of collegiality. Pope Leo stressed that he was there to listen, following a path of synodality. The purpose was not to produce a text, but to engage in a conversation that would help the Pope "in serving the mission of the entire Church" (Pope Leo, 7 January 2026).

On 9 January, Pope Leo addressed members of the Diplomatic Corps accredited to Holy See. He highlighted St. Augustine's work The City of God, in which the earthly city is focused on pride, self-love, and thirst for power, while the city of God is focused on love, both God's love, and human love, love of one's neighbor and especially of the poor. Pope Leo deplored that in these times zeal for war is spreading, as the rule of law is threatened. He went on to insist that the Holy See is ready "to support any initiative that promotes peace and harmony" (Pope Leo, 9 January 2026).

Insisting that Peru occupies a special place in his heart, a place where he "experienced the strength of a Church that knows how to hope even in the midst of trials," Pope Leo addressed on 30 January the bishops of Peru, in Rome for their ad limina visit. He urged them to look to St. Paul as an example to follow in going out to meet people, to listen to them, to accompany them, to understand them, and to bring them to God (Pope Leo, 30 January 2026).

Many are watching to see how similar or not this papacy is with that of Pope Francis. I leave to others to consider how Pope Leo's preferences in papal and liturgical dress stand in comparison with the sartorial practices of Pope Francis. But Pope Leo's episcopal appointments thus far suggest a great deal of continuity with Francis's priorities; we shall see if this also proves to be the case in Pope Leo's naming of cardinals. Forthcoming decisions on beatifications and canonizations will also be significant barometers of this papacy. Approval for beatification of Fulton Sheen has been announced: an American priest (and eventually a bishop) who deftly used in the 1950s and 60s the then relatively new medium of television to catechize and evangelize many millions of people. Where travels take Pope Leo we shall see, though he has already mentioned Africa and parts of South America. It is rumored that he will attend the 2028 Eucharistic congress in Australia. Might one or more stops in Asia be added to such a trip? A speech in New York at a United Nations assembly seems likely within the next year or two, especially since the Pope has pointed to the UN, not to President Trump's efforts, as the best way to manage peace in Gaza. A visit to the UN would almost certainly include some other stops in New York City, and maybe even be followed by a visit to Chicago, Pope Leo's hometown.

 


Thomas Worcester, SJ, Professor of History, Fordham University, New York.


REFERENCES

  • 'Cardinal Stephen Chow meets with Pope Leo XIV for the First Time since the Conclave', (19 December 2025), in Sunday Examiner.org.hk.
  • Gates, L.G. (15 June 2025), 'Finding the Pope's Roots', New York Times Magazine, 26–33.
  • Luscome, B. (28 July 2025), 'The Making of the Pope', Time Magazine, 26–31.
  • Mong, A. (January 2026), A Lion Returns to Rome: The Legacy of Leo XIII, The Way 65/1, 97–113.
  • Pope Leo XIV. (18 May 2025), Homily for the Beginning of the Pontificate. Dicastery for Communication.
  • Pope Leo XIV. (5 September 2025), Homily for Blessing of the Borgo Laudato si'. Dicastery for Communication.
  • Pope Leo XIV. (4 October 2025), Apostolic Exhortation Dilexi Te on Love for the Poor. Dicastery for Communication.
  • Pope Leo XIV. (1 November 2025), Homily for the Jubilee of Education and the Proclamation of St. John Henry Newman as a Doctor of the Church. Dicastery for Communication.
  • Pope Leo XIV. (23 November 2025), Apostolic Letter In Unitate Fidei. Dicastery for Communication.
  • Pope Leo XIV. (5 December 2025), Address to Organizers of the Concert with the Poor. Dicastery for Communication.
  • Pope Leo XIV. (22 December 2025), Address to the Roman Curia. Dicastery for Communication.
  • Pope Leo XIV. (25 December 2025), Homily for the Solemnity of Christmas During the Day. Dicastery for Communication.
  • Pope Leo XIV. (6 January 2026), Homily for the Solemnity of Epiphany and the Closing of the Holy Door. Dicastery for Communication.
  • Pope Leo XIV. (7 January 2026), Address for the Opening of the Extraordinary Consistory of Cardinals. Dicastery for Communication.
  • Pope Leo XIV. (9 January 2026), Address to Members of the Diplomatic Corps. Dicastery for Communication.
  • Pope Leo XIV. (30 January 2026), Address to the Bishops of Peru. Dicastery for Communication.
  • Pope Francis. (22 December 2014), Address to the Roman Curia. Dicastery for Communication.
  • Smith, J.K.A. (July/August 2025), 'What to Expect from an Augustinian Pope', America Magazine, 42–44.
  • Taj, M., Turewitz, J., and Glatsky, G. (9 May 2025), 'In Chiclayo, Peru, Locals Cheer the "Peruvian Pope"', New York Times.

Click here to view the PDF version